Color is for Kids
Monday, May 25th, 2009
When I was growing up, I remember thinking I didn’t like black and white movies. I realize now that it’s mostly because black and white movies weren’t often targeted to kids. If a movie was done in black and white, it was usually a serious, grown-up movie. I mean, there’s nothing that would have made me sit through The Grapes of Wrath when I was a kid. Of course, even as a grown-up I wouldn’t want to watch it a second time. It’s just too depressing.
I understand the artistic choice to film in black and white, but I also feel there’s a lot of beauty and nature and, yes, color, in the story of The Grapes of Wrath. The land that they reach in California is so green and fertile. I’ve been there, I know. But this long and treacherous road to get there, the bleakness and hopelessness of their situation, is not lifted when they reach that land. They’re still hungry, and they’re still dusty and poor. I guess it’s the richness of Steinbeck’s language in the book that gives it so much color and vibrancy, despite the perils the Joads face on that long road.
Perhaps another impactful approach might have been to take some pointers from another road trip film released one year earlier – The Wizard of Oz. Dorothy’s scenes on the farm in Kansas are filmed in black and white. Her life is drab and depressing, but when she reaches Oz, everything is in vibrant color. It takes her the entire story to figure out this place is not the promised land she might have hoped for.
It wouldn’t have taken the Joads that long once they made it to California. But wouldn’t it have been cool to see everything in black and white and then for just a few brief scenes we see the vibrant green and the blue skies of California before it fades to black and white just as quickly as the color appeared? Nah, that’s just silly kids’ stuff.
